Representing the Injured since 1926
Injured? Call 800-689-7066

New Jersey rail employee case may have California implications

A New Jersey rail worker’s claim for benefits has been reinstated by an appeals court, allowing the case to proceed. The result may have implications for California rail workers.

At issue is a rail employee who fainted from overexposure to diesel and exhaust fumes from trucks while working in a rail tunnel in 2012. The worker was taken to a hospital where no physical damage was found.

The worker, a signal designer for Port Authority Trans Hudson Corp. identified as M.M., was placed under a psychiatrist’s care and returned to work one year after the incident, but quit several days later and then sued for emotional distress claiming she suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder.

FELA requirement for emotional distress

The Federal Employers Liability Act (FELA) covers railroad workers for emotional distress if the claim meets the “zone of danger” test – if the worker was placed in immediate risk of physical harm by the railroad or another defendant but escaped physical injury.

A New Jersey judge initially issued summary judgement, ruling ruled that M.M.’s case did not meet the “zone of danger” test. The judge cited a previous ruling that found a worker who was exposed to asbestos but was free of disease did not meet the test. If asbestos exposure didn’t meet the test, the judge reasoned, then diesel fumes wouldn’t meet the test either.

On appeal, M.M.’s legal team argued that, among other issues, the two cases were separate because in the asbestos case, the plaintiff sued because of his fear of contracting an illness in the future but M.M. had sustained an immediate symptom by fainting. M.M.’s PTSD developed after and as a result of fainting from the fumes.

M.M. suffered a physical impact from fumes

The appeals court agreed, saying that the case should be heard because M.M. did suffer physical impact which led to emotional distress.

FELA is the federal law that protects railroad workers and sets de-facto safety standards across the nation. The law has been in place since 1908 and provides both employees and companies with a uniform liability standard. Rulings in one state can apply to rail workers in any state across the nation.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Us To Schedule A Free Consultation

Call us toll free at 800-689-7066 or use the email contact form to tell us about the circumstances of your injury or wrongful death case. We offer a free consultation and handle all FELA, FRSA and personal injury litigation matters on a contingency-fee basis. No fees unless we help you recover financial damages in a settlement or trial verdict.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Email us for response

Our locations

350 Frank H. Ogawa Plaza
4th Floor
Oakland, CA 94612

Toll Free: 800-689-7066
Fax: 510-465-7023
Map & Directions

700 North Brand Blvd.
Suite 860
Glendale, CA 91203

Toll Free: 800-689-7066
Fax: 323-669-8549
Map & Directions